Plan denies hospitalization and is ordered to reimburse costs

The affected person doesn’t want to know intimately the phrases stipulated between the well being plan and its accredited community. Additionally, lack of readability relating to any restrictions on providers or processes violates the fundamental guidelines of the Consumer Protection Code (CDC).

With this reasoning, the fifth Civil Panel of the Colegio Recursal de Santos upheld a person’s acquittal enchantment and sentenced Notre Dame Intermedica Saude to reimburse R$ 13,658.53. This quantity refers to costs paid by the writer to Hospital Casa de Saúde Guarujá, ensuing from hospitalization for a interval of seven days.

The well being plan denied entry to the Casa de Saúde as a result of she was not acknowledged for the contract. The defendant additionally acknowledged in response that it supplied an ambulance to a corporation in its community situated within the neighboring municipality of Santos, to take away the affected person from the hospital in Guruja, the town the place the companion lives.

Judge Alexandre das Neves of the Special Civil Court of Guaruja dismissed the motion. “It stays undisputed on document that the writer was admitted to a hospital outdoors the accredited community of his well being plan”, it dominated. a lawyer Geraldo de Souza Sobrinho appealed and reiterated the existence of a hyperlink between the respondent and the Casa de Saúde.

The appellate judgment was transformed into diligence, seeking appropriate data relating to the validity or in any other case of Guruja Hospital. “The hospital confirms the contract of providers it supplies and additionally sends the contract it maintains with the defendant”, emphasised the reporter Judge Dario Gayoso Jr.

Based on this documentary proof, Notre Dame Intermédica innovated its protection and introduced the argument that there was no urgency or emergency within the affected person’s admission to the hospital, “abandoning the allegation that the hospital doesn’t belong to its accredited community”, Gayoso noticed.

According to the reporter, the settlement between the scheme and Guruja Hospital has not been proven to the beneficiaries and there is no proof that the respondent informs, “clearly and emphatically that the Consumer Protection Code requires”, the alleged restriction that the service shall be fast/emergency solely on this unit.

“Everything signifies that the defendant intends to switch the affected person as a result of the hospital in Guruja will value greater than the accredited hospital in Santos”, Gayoso concluded. The reporter’s opinion was adopted by judges Claudio Teixeira Villar and Walter Luiz Esteves de Azevedo.

No ethical damages
The quantity to be reimbursed, from the date of fee made by the writer to the hospital, shall be topic to monetary revision and calculated from the date of service, statutory curiosity on late fee at 1% monthly. Sobrinho additionally sought condemnation of the plan for ethical damages, however solely “materials damages for breach of contract” for Collegiate.

The lawyer initially acknowledged that the shopper was admitted to Casa de Saude Guruja on July 4, 2021 due to problems arising from Covid-19. The writer had respiratory failure and extreme chest ache, and fast admission to this hospital was indicated.

Still in accordance to Sobrinho, due to the dearth of authorization for the hospitalization plan, the delay of a number of hours in sending an ambulance to take the affected person to Santos, and the deterioration of the scientific situation throughout this ready interval, “the writer had no different selection. Assume all of the hospital bills.”

Justifying the declare for compensation for ethical damages, the lawyer stated that “the failure to present the providers straight affected the psychological situation of the plaintiff, inflicting him nice misery and struggling, primarily as a result of he was strictly paying the month-to-month charges of the well being scheme, however he felt. Helpless when he wanted to use it.”

Process 1008789-49.2021.8.26.0223


Leave a Comment