Referee failure in EM remaining: Why didn’t anyone notice the handball?

The extra you watch this scene the clearer it turns into. Maybe referee Caterina Monzul ought to have watched the motion once more in the overview space, perhaps video referees Paolo Valeri and Paul van Boeckel ought to have checked out it from a special perspective, perhaps the German gamers ought to have complained extra vehemently.

Everything stays in the subjunctive, as the scene is initially misplaced in the residing motion. It is the twenty fifth minute of the sport in the European Championship remaining between England and Germany. At one nook, issues get messy in entrance of the lioness’s field. On the discipline, the ball hit the palms of England captain Leigh Williamson simply in entrance of the objective line.

The Ukrainian referee permits the sport to proceed, however the subsequent time the sport is stopped, he’s knowledgeable that the scene is being reviewed. A brief break, then observe: No penalty!

The referee group is out of the query

Apparently, the video assistants weren’t capable of establish any punishable handballs. Unreachable, as a result of the arm is away from the physique and stretched excessive in the air. Because it occurs solely centimeters from the objective line, the brief distance argument should not actually maintain.

When “Bild” Monzul reacted to the scene after the sport, she is claimed to have merely shrugged her shoulders. Video colleague Valery defined to the newspaper in the combined zone that he was not allowed to touch upon it. There is not any clarification from UEFA.

The pleasure in the German group is comprehensible – however why is the outcry so late in the context of stay occasions?

EM Finals: Why Handball Loses Early?

National coach Martina Voss-Tecklenberg, for instance, sees the scene along with her colleagues from ARD solely after the remaining whistle, after which she not is aware of that the handball was even checked. “You must see that. Yes, I do not know if it was checked or not. But there is no use complaining now. Of course it is silly. The individuals accountable ought to give it some thought.”

Handball went down each on and off the discipline. No marvel one thing like this occurs in a fraction of a second. But even the TV viewer realizes the scope of the scene a lot later.

Commentator Bernd Schmelzer assesses the motion in stay motion as follows whereas watching the first replay: “And right here comes the ball, no, it isn’t a deliberate handball. It will now be checked by the video assistant.” Although he additionally agrees that the hand is “proportionately excessive”, he thinks the remaining resolution is “anticipated”.

ARD human error, as intent or not will not be vital to the analysis of this example. The unnatural extension of Williamson’s physique is essential.

Voss-Tecklenburg seeks to make clear the flawed resolution

The worldwide course leaves him on these direct repetitions, which is why Schmelzer does not get a greater foundation for his evaluation at half-time. The commentator doesn’t appear to have acquired any info from his crew both.

Just throughout the break ARD goes into extra element on the scene with moderator Klaus Luffen and knowledgeable Nia Kunzer. Even the TV viewer right here is aware of: there was a penalty fraud in Germany!

The discipline interviews with nationwide coaches Luffen and Kunzer turn out to be clearer with extra distance in the sport. “At this stage in a European Championship remaining, one thing like that should not occur. I would like you to cope with it. I do not need individuals to only brush it off,” she pleaded.

And additional: “My query is: Why does this occur, why is it not seen? Why is there no clear communication? That’s what drives me and retains me busy.”

Legitimate questions that UEFA nonetheless must reply.

Leave a Comment